​As of March 2025, Siesta Key's real estate market presents a dynamic landscape for prospective buyers and investors. The median home price on the island stands at approximately $1 million, reflecting a 7.8% year-over-year increase. However, within specific neighborhoods like Siesta Key Village, there's a noticeable decline, with median sold prices dropping by 12% to $912,500 . Inventory levels have risen by 9.3% from February to March 2025, offering 481 homes for sale . Despite these fluctuations, the market remains competitive, with many properties selling below asking price . This trend suggests a shift towards a buyer's market, providing opportunities for those looking to invest in Siesta Key's unique coastal community.​
Median Sale Price
# of Homes Sold
Median Days on Market
Your Comprehensive Guide to Siesta Key Real Estate
Siesta Key offers a wide range of homes for sale, including beachfront properties, single-family homes, luxury estates, and condos. Many properties offer stunning views of the Gulf of Mexico or Sarasota Bay, with options ranging from cozy cottages to large, upscale residences.
The real estate market in Siesta Key is competitive, with high demand for waterfront properties and vacation homes. Home values have been steadily increasing due to the area's popularity as a vacation destination and the limited availability of prime real estate. Inventory tends to be low, making it a seller’s market.
The price of homes in Siesta Key varies greatly depending on location and property type. Single-family homes typically range from around $500,000 to several million dollars for luxury waterfront estates. Condos can start around $300,000 and go up to $2 million or more for units with prime views and amenities.
Popular neighborhoods in Siesta Key include the Beach Road area, which offers beachfront properties, and the Siesta Key Village, known for its proximity to shops, restaurants, and entertainment. Other sought-after areas include Hidden Harbor and Point of Rocks for those seeking a quieter, more private setting.
When buying a home in Siesta Key, consider factors such as proximity to the beach, flood risk, and whether the property is in a rental zone if you’re interested in vacation rentals. Additionally, check for any homeowner association rules, especially for condos, and assess the maintenance costs for waterfront properties.
To find a reliable real estate agent in Siesta Key, FL, you can start by exploring online platforms. Additionally, you may consider reaching out to The VanDuren Group, they are a reputable real estate team known for their proficiency in Hot Siesta Key market. You can contact them directly for personalized assistance and guidance in your real estate endeavors.
Request More Information
Looking to buy, sell, or just have a question? We are always available to help and would love to work with you. Contact us today to find out how we can be of assistance to you!
